On December 24th, five seemingly random men are invited to a dive bar by a mysterious e-mail. They decide to pass the time by resurrecting the old tradition of telling scary stories on Christmas Eve.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Jess AndersonAmber | Amber |
| CChristopher BowerRed | Red |
| JJoseph CabanDaytime reporter | Daytime reporter |
| SSteve ChristopherKringles The Christmas Clown | Kringles The Christmas Clown |
 Dixie GersNews reporter | News reporter |
 Ryan KingClarence | Clarence |
| DDavid E. McMahonCarl | Carl |
| MMichael MerchantPeter | Peter |
| CCassondra BrianMother | Mother |
| IIan F. ScottThe Artist | The Artist |
 Briar BoggsThe Photographer | The Photographer |
| BBlair HoyleThe Victim | The Victim |
 Julie Anne PrescottNight Reporter (segment "Digging up the Ghost") | Night Reporter (segment "Digging up the Ghost") |
 Sadie KatzDr. Hershberger (segment "A Christmas To Dismember") | Dr. Hershberger (segment "A Christmas To Dismember") |
 Kevin ClarkHoward | Howard |
| GGerrimy KeifferNew Guy | New Guy |
 Jeffrey ReddickReporter Alexander Browning | Reporter Alexander Browning |
| GGreg HarpoldTed | Ted |