 Anastasia ElfmanBabysitter (segment "Overkill") | Babysitter (segment "Overkill") |
 Jennifer NangleMalvolia (segment "Malvolias Halloween Monster Marathon") | Malvolia (segment "Malvolias Halloween Monster Marathon") |
 London GraceMrs McClaron ("A Samhain Liturgy") / Sister Mary ("Sister Mary") | Mrs McClaron ("A Samhain Liturgy") / Sister Mary ("Sister Mary") |
 Bianca AllaineThe Woman (segment "Treaters") | The Woman (segment "Treaters") |
| MMatt BlockThe Man / Devil (segment "Sister Mary") | The Man / Devil (segment "Sister Mary") |
 Lauren FogleHot Chick (segment "Overkill") | Hot Chick (segment "Overkill") |
 Jordan BeltzAllison (segment "Treaters") | Allison (segment "Treaters") |
 Sable GriedelKira (segment "Treaters") | Kira (segment "Treaters") |
| MMarissa SabatucciRachel (segment "Treaters") | Rachel (segment "Treaters") |
| AAdam HershbergerNarrator (segment "Treaters") (voice | Narrator (segment "Treaters") (voice |
| MMark CombsChristine (segment "Trucksquatch") | Christine (segment "Trucksquatch") |
| WWilliam DavisThe Husband (segment "The Candy Taker") | The Husband (segment "The Candy Taker") |
| GGreg PalinkasThe Friend (segment "The Candy Taker") | The Friend (segment "The Candy Taker") |
| AAngelina PrendergastThe Screamer (segment "The Candy Taker") | The Screamer (segment "The Candy Taker") |
| CChristopher HobanLuis (segment "The October Kids") | Luis (segment "The October Kids") |
| LLexi BreuerTara (segment "The October Kids") | Tara (segment "The October Kids") |
| EEmily SwensonJenna (segment "The October Kids") | Jenna (segment "The October Kids") |
| RR.J. WagnerStan (segment "A Samhain Liturgy") | Stan (segment "A Samhain Liturgy") |
 Chad BrunsTim (segment "Treaters") | Tim (segment "Treaters") |
| GGabriel BulthaupBaby (segment "Sister Mary") | Baby (segment "Sister Mary") |
| TTim NovotnyCreature / Cocaine Guy #2 (segment "A Samhain Liturgy") | Creature / Cocaine Guy #2 (segment "A Samhain Liturgy") |
| TTania HendersonHolly's Mom (segment "A Samhain Liturgy") | Holly's Mom (segment "A Samhain Liturgy") |
| TTy SellsCameron (segment "A Samhain Liturgy") | Cameron (segment "A Samhain Liturgy") |
| RRhema SrihartitiHolly (segment "A Samhain Liturgy") | Holly (segment "A Samhain Liturgy") |
| ZZeke HansonPolice Officer (segment "The October Kids") | Police Officer (segment "The October Kids") |
| JJessica BreuerKevin's Mom (segment "The October Kids") | Kevin's Mom (segment "The October Kids") |
| MMaddox BreuerKevin (segment "The October Kids") | Kevin (segment "The October Kids") |
